School #21

Dialectical Materialism

Marx, Engels

Dialectical Materialism holds that reality is fundamentally material and develops through contradictions — opposing forces whose conflict drives all change in nature, society, and thought. Karl Marx's 'Capital' (1867) demonstrated this method in action, analyzing how the internal contradictions of capitalism (between labor and capital, use-value and exchange-value) generate crises that propel historical transformation. His 'Theses on Feuerbach' (1845) declared that "philosophers have only interpreted the world; the point is to change it." Friedrich Engels's 'Dialectics of Nature' (written 1873-86) and 'Anti-Duhring' (1878) extended the dialectical method to the natural sciences, arguing that the laws of dialectics — the transformation of quantity into quality, the interpenetration of opposites, the negation of the negation — operate in physics, chemistry, and biology just as they do in human history.

Worldview

The dialectical materialist experiences reality as a field of concrete contradictions in motion, where every stable arrangement conceals the tensions that will eventually transform it. The world is not a collection of static objects but a dynamic process driven by the clash of opposing material forces. To hold this ontology is to see history everywhere: in the organization of a factory, the price of bread, and the shape of a city, one reads the unfolding logic of material conditions and class struggle. The fundamental orientation is activist and forward-looking, animated by the conviction that understanding the laws of historical development makes revolutionary transformation not only possible but necessary. Reality is solid, material, and knowable, yet perpetually in the process of becoming something else through its own internal contradictions. The framework classifies this as None: agency runs entirely through material and social-historical causation; no personal deity or cosmic ordering principle stands above the dialectic of matter in motion. The framework reads this as Constructed moral authority: norms are products of material-historical conditions and the struggles of constituted classes; no Scripture, Tradition, or transhistorical Reason is granted finality outside the dialectical movement of social practice.

Moral Implications

Morality in dialectical materialism is not an abstract set of timeless principles but a reflection of the material conditions and class interests of a given historical epoch. What the ruling class calls "justice" typically serves to legitimize the existing relations of production, making ethical critique inseparable from economic analysis. The overriding moral imperative is the liberation of the working class from exploitation, and all ethical judgments are evaluated by their contribution to this emancipatory project. Solidarity, collective action, and the subordination of individual advantage to the common good of the oppressed constitute the core virtues. Bourgeois morality, with its emphasis on individual rights and private property, is understood as historically contingent and destined to be superseded by the ethics of a classless society.

Practical Implications

Dialectical materialism demands the reorganization of economic life around collective ownership of the means of production, with profound consequences for labor, governance, and social welfare. Technology is evaluated not for its abstract efficiency but for its role in either deepening exploitation or enabling liberation; automation, for instance, is welcomed only if its benefits are collectively shared. Environmental policy follows from the recognition that the exploitation of nature and the exploitation of labor share a common root in the capitalist mode of production. In daily life, the dialectical materialist prioritizes class consciousness, union organizing, and political education, understanding individual choices as meaningful primarily through their relation to collective material transformation.

I. Time

Time is substantival and infinite — it is the real medium in which the dialectical development of material reality unfolds. History moves through time via the dialectical process: thesis, antithesis, synthesis. Time is continuous, linear, and deterministic in the sense that historical development follows necessary laws of material contradiction and resolution.

Attributes
Extent: Infinite Ontological Status: Substantival Grain: Continuous Freedom: Deterministic Traversability: Linear Dimensionality: One Direction: Uni-directional

II. Space

Space is substantival, finite, and flat — it is the real, material environment in which social relations of production are organized. Space is local and three-dimensional: material conditions and class structures are always concretely situated in particular places. The spatial organization of production shapes all aspects of social life.

Attributes
Extent: Finite Ontological Status: Substantival Curvature: Flat Dimensionality: Three Locality: Local

III. Matter

Matter is substantival and finite — it is the fundamental reality from which all phenomena arise through dialectical interaction. Matter is conserved and local: material conditions are the base on which all superstructure (law, culture, ideology) rests. The dialectical laws of nature — the unity and struggle of opposites, the transformation of quantity into quality — govern all material processes.

Attributes
Extent: Finite Ontological Status: Substantival Conservation: Conserved Dimensionality: Three Locality: Local

IV. Observer

The observer is a materially situated, historically embedded being — rooted in a specific time, place, and set of social relations that shape what it can see and know. Consciousness is not a passive mirror but an active force: the observer transforms reality through labor and collective praxis, and is in turn transformed by the material conditions it inhabits. Knowledge begins with immediate experience but accumulates through dialectical struggle — thesis, antithesis, synthesis — building a progressively deeper understanding of historical and material processes. The observer is embodied and plural: revolution is a collective act, and truth emerges through the clash of opposing social forces.

Attributes
Time Instance: Single Space Instance: Single Extent of Knowledge: Mediated Retainment of Knowledge: Partial Physicality: Embodied Agency: Active Number: Plural Metaphysical Agency: None Moral Authority: Constructed Theological Method: N/A

V. Energy

Energy is substantival and finite — it is a real, material quantity governed by natural law. Conservation is strict: the dialectical transformation of matter and energy follows necessary physical laws. Dispersibility is irreversible, reflecting the directional development of material processes through dialectical contradictions.

Attributes
Extent: Finite Ontological Status: Substantival Conservation: Conserved Dispersibility: Irreversible

VI. Information

Information is an emergent property of material processes — it arises from the dialectical interactions of matter in motion. The framework distinguishes scales: information is conserved at the cosmic scale (material processes preserve their informational structure across dialectical transformations), but non-conserved at the personal-identity scale — the individual, as a material configuration, dissolves at death with no surviving pattern.

Attributes
Ontological Status: Emergent Cosmic Conservation: Conserved Personal Conservation: Non-conserved Granularity: Continuous

Experiments This School Responds To (3)

Films Reading Through This School (1)

Debates Where This School Is Allied (9)

← #20 Postmodernism All Schools #22 Absurdism →

Works that name Dialectical Materialism in their embodiments

Foundational texts that draw on this school, with each work's declared weight.

55%
Capital, Volume I (Late)
Karl Marx · 1867 (German first ed.); Volume II 1885, Volume III 1894 (posthumous, ed. Engels)
55%
The Communist Manifesto (Early)
Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels · February 1848 (commissioned by the Communist League, London)
55%
Theses on Feuerbach (Early)
Karl Marx · 1845 (notebook fragments, published posthumously by Engels in 1888 with slight editorial changes)
45%
The State and Revolution (Late)
Vladimir Lenin · 1917 (composed in Finland, on the eve of the October Revolution)
45%
Capital (Late)
Karl Marx · 1867 (vol. I); 1885 (vol. II posthumous); 1894 (vol. III posthumous, edited by Engels)
40%
The German Ideology (Early)
Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels · 1845-46 (composed in Brussels; published 1932 by Soviet Union)
40%
Anti-Duhring (Late)
Friedrich Engels · 1877-78
35%
Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844 (Early)
Karl Marx · Paris, summer 1844 (notebook manuscripts; unfinished and unpublished in Marx's lifetime); first published 1932
35%
Prison Notebooks (Late)
Antonio Gramsci · 1929-35 (composed in fascist prison); 1948-51 (posthumous Italian publication)
35%
History and Class Consciousness (Mid)
György Lukács · 1923
30%
Critique of Dialectical Reason (Late (Sartre's major late philosophical work))
Jean-Paul Sartre · 1960 (vol. I); vol. II unfinished, published posthumously 1985
30%
Seven Interpretive Essays on Peruvian Reality (Siete ensayos de interpretación de la realidad peruana) (Mid)
José Carlos Mariátegui · 1928
30%
A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy (Mature)
Karl Marx · 1859
30%
Capital, Volume II (Late)
Karl Marx · c. 1865-78 (drafts); 1885 (Engels-edited publication)
30%
Capital, Volume III (Late)
Karl Marx · c. 1864-75 (drafts); 1894 (Engels-edited publication)
30%
Grundrisse (Mature)
Karl Marx · 1857-58
25%
Dialectic of Enlightenment (Mid)
Theodor W. Adorno and Max Horkheimer · 1944 (private circulation); 1947 (Amsterdam edition)
25%
Negative Dialectics (Late)
Theodor W. Adorno · 1966 (German; English 1973)
25%
One-Dimensional Man (Late)
Herbert Marcuse · 1964
25%
Theses on the Philosophy of History (Late)
Walter Benjamin · 1940 (German; English 1968)
25%
The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction (Late)
Walter Benjamin · 1935-36 (multiple versions); first published 1936 in French
25%
Women, Race & Class (Mid)
Angela Y. Davis · 1981
25%
Mother Courage and Her Children (Late)
Bertolt Brecht · 1939 (composed in Swedish exile); 1941 (Zurich premiere)
22%
Specters of Marx (Late)
Jacques Derrida · 1993
22%
The Self-Identity of Absolute Contradiction (Late)
Nishida Kitarō · 1939
20%
Phenomenology of Spirit (Early)
Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel · 1806–07 (finished as Napoleon entered Jena)
20%
Discourse on the Origin of Inequality (Mid (between the First Discourse and the Social Contract))
Jean-Jacques Rousseau · 1755 (submitted to the 1754 essay competition of the Académie de Dijon, on the question of the origin and justification of inequality)
20%
Lectures on the Philosophy of History (Late (Berlin lectures of the 1820s, his mature mature))
Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel · 1822-31 (delivered as lectures); 1837 (compiled and published posthumously by Eduard Gans)
20%
Minima Moralia: Reflections from Damaged Life (Mid)
Theodor W. Adorno · 1944-47 (composed); 1951 (published)
20%
Eclipse of Reason (Mid)
Max Horkheimer · 1947 (English original; German edition 1967)
20%
Eros and Civilization (Mid)
Herbert Marcuse · 1955
20%
The Wretched of the Earth (Late)
Frantz Fanon · 1961 (French; English 1963)
20%
Can the Subaltern Speak? (Mid)
Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak · 1988 (essay in Marxism and the Interpretation of Culture; rev. 1999 in Critique of Postcolonial Reason)
20%
Toward the African Revolution (Late)
Frantz Fanon · 1952-1961 essays; 1964 (collection)
20%
The Sublime Object of Ideology (Mid)
Slavoj Žižek · 1989
20%
Ways of Seeing (Late)
John Berger · 1972 (BBC series and book)
20%
Canto General (Mid)
Pablo Neruda · 1938-49 (composed in exile and underground); 1950 (Mexico City and Santiago)
20%
Reflections on the Causes of Liberty and Social Oppression (Early)
Simone Weil · 1934
18%
Prophesy Deliverance! (Early)
Cornel West · 1982
18%
The Arcades Project (Career-spanning (unfinished))
Walter Benjamin · 1927-1940 (unfinished at Benjamin's 1940 death; published posthumously 1982)
16%
Philosophy of New Music (Middle)
Theodor Adorno · 1940-48 composition; 1949 publication
16%
Aesthetic Theory (Final)
Theodor Adorno · 1961-1969 (left unfinished at death); 1970 posthumous publication
15%
Theory of Communicative Action
Jürgen Habermas · 1981 (German, 2 vols)
15%
Elements of the Philosophy of Right (Late (the mature systematic philosophy))
Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel · 1820 (published 1821 with the famous controversial Preface)
15%
Science of Logic (Mid (the central work of the mature Hegelian system))
Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel · 1812 (Book I, Being); 1813 (Book II, Essence); 1816 (Book III, Concept); 1832 (Hegel's revised Book I, posthumous)
15%
The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere (Early (the breakthrough work))
Jürgen Habermas · 1962 (habilitation thesis; English translation 1989)
15%
The Origin of German Tragic Drama (Early (the most ambitious early work, before the Arcades Project))
Walter Benjamin · 1925 (submitted as habilitation thesis, rejected by the University of Frankfurt); 1928 (published commercially)
15%
Principles of Political Economy (Mid (Mill's major economic work))
John Stuart Mill · 1848 (1st edition); revised through 1871 (7th edition)
15%
Knowledge and Human Interests (Early)
Jürgen Habermas · 1968 (German; English 1971)
15%
Orientalism (Mid)
Edward W. Said · 1978
15%
Culture and Imperialism (Late)
Edward W. Said · 1993
15%
Feminist Theory: From Margin to Center (Early)
bell hooks · 1984
15%
A Theology of Liberation (Early (Gutiérrez's breakthrough work; the founding text of the school))
Gustavo Gutiérrez · 1971 (Spanish); 1973 (English)
15%
Toward a Feminist Theory of the State (Mid)
Catharine A. MacKinnon · 1989
15%
Anti-Oedipus: Capitalism and Schizophrenia, vol. 1 (Late)
Gilles Deleuze and Félix Guattari · 1972
15%
Philosophy of Liberation (Filosofía de la Liberación) (Mid)
Enrique Dussel · 1977
15%
Church: Charism and Power (Igreja: carisma e poder) (Mid)
Leonardo Boff · 1981
15%
Escape from Freedom (Mid)
Erich Fromm · 1941
15%
The Sociological Imagination (Mid)
C. Wright Mills · 1959
15%
Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste (La Distinction) (Mid)
Pierre Bourdieu · 1979
15%
The Culture of Narcissism (Late)
Christopher Lasch · 1979
15%
Capital in the Twenty-First Century (Le Capital au XXIe siècle) (Late)
Thomas Piketty · 2013 (French); 2014 (English)
15%
The Shock Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Capitalism (Late)
Naomi Klein · 2007
15%
Thought and Language (Mid)
Lev Vygotsky · 1934 (posthumous, Vygotsky died June 1934)
15%
Decolonising the Mind (Late)
Ngũgĩ wa Thiong'o · 1986 (based on 1984 Robb Lectures)
15%
The Power of the Poor in History (Mid)
Gustavo Gutiérrez · 1979 (Spanish), 1983 (English)
15%
Dialectic: The Pulse of Freedom (Late)
Roy Bhaskar · 1993
14%
A Dying Colonialism (Middle (during Algerian war))
Frantz Fanon · 1959
14%
Factory Journal (Middle)
Simone Weil · 1934-1935; published posthumously 1951
12%
Black Prophetic Fire (Late)
Cornel West · 2014
12%
The Roads to Freedom (Middle)
Jean-Paul Sartre · 1945-1949 (three published volumes)
10%
The Second Sex
Simone de Beauvoir · 1949 (French two-vol. ed.)
10%
An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations (Late)
Adam Smith · 1776 (first ed.); five revised editions in Smith's lifetime
10%
Discipline and Punish (Late)
Michel Foucault · 1975
10%
Existentialism Is a Humanism
Jean-Paul Sartre · 29 October 1945 (Paris lecture); 1946 (published)
10%
On Revolution (Late (after Eichmann in Jerusalem))
Hannah Arendt · 1963
10%
Moral Man and Immoral Society (Early-mid (Niebuhr's breakthrough book that established Christian realism))
Reinhold Niebuhr · 1932
10%
Encyclopaedia of the Philosophical Sciences (Mature (the most comprehensive single-text statement of the system))
Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel · 1817 (1st edition); 1827 (2nd edition); 1830 (3rd and definitive edition, in three volumes)
10%
Lectures on the Philosophy of Religion (Late (Berlin lectures))
Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel · 1821-31 (delivered as lectures); 1832 (compiled and published posthumously)
10%
On Nature (Fragments)
Heraclitus of Ephesus · c. 500 BC (the fragments preserved through later authors' quotations)
10%
A Cyborg Manifesto (Mid)
Donna Haraway · 1985 (first published in Socialist Review)
10%
Black Skin, White Masks (Early)
Frantz Fanon · 1952 (French; English 1967)
10%
Between Facts and Norms (Late)
Jürgen Habermas · 1992 (German; English 1996)
10%
The Philosophical Discourse of Modernity (Mid)
Jürgen Habermas · 1985 (German; English 1987)
10%
The Elementary Structures of Kinship (Early (Lévi-Strauss's breakthrough work; the foundation of structural anthropology))
Claude Lévi-Strauss · 1949
10%
Theology of Hope (Early)
Jürgen Moltmann · 1964 (German; English 1967)
10%
Spheres of Justice (Mid)
Michael Walzer · 1983
10%
Justice and the Politics of Difference (Mid)
Iris Marion Young · 1990
10%
Mapping the Margins: Intersectionality, Identity Politics, and Violence against Women of Color (Mid)
Kimberlé Crenshaw · 1991 (Stanford Law Review)
10%
Utopia (De Optimo Reipublicae Statu deque Nova Insula Utopia) (Mid)
St. Thomas More · 1516
10%
A Thousand Plateaus: Capitalism and Schizophrenia, vol. 2 (Late)
Gilles Deleuze and Félix Guattari · 1980
10%
Simulacra and Simulation (Simulacres et simulation) (Late)
Jean Baudrillard · 1981
10%
The Idea of Latin America (Late)
Walter D. Mignolo · 2005
10%
Critique of Cynical Reason (Kritik der zynischen Vernunft) (Mid)
Peter Sloterdijk · 1983
10%
A Theology for the Social Gospel (Late)
Walter Rauschenbusch · 1917
10%
Christ the Liberator: A View from the Victims (Late)
Jon Sobrino · 1999 (Spanish); 2001 (English)
10%
Black Feminist Thought (Mid)
Patricia Hill Collins · 1990 (2nd edn 2000)
10%
A Room of One's Own (Late)
Virginia Woolf · 1929
10%
The Social Construction of Reality (Mid)
Peter L. Berger and Thomas Luckmann · 1966
10%
Liquid Modernity (Late)
Zygmunt Bauman · 2000
10%
The Fall of Public Man (Mid)
Richard Sennett · 1977
10%
The Logic of Practice (Late)
Pierre Bourdieu · 1980 (French); 1990 (English)
10%
The Possibility of Naturalism (Mid)
Roy Bhaskar · 1979 (1st ed.); 1989 (2nd ed.); 1998 (3rd ed.)
10%
Simians, Cyborgs, and Women (Mid)
Donna Haraway · 1991
10%
Modest_Witness@Second_Millennium.FemaleMan©_Meets_OncoMouse™ (Late)
Donna Haraway · 1997
10%
Critique of Black Reason (Late)
Achille Mbembe · 2013 (French), 2017 (English)
10%
Reclaiming Reality (Mid)
Roy Bhaskar · 1989
10%
Old Tales Retold (Gushi Xinbian) (Late)
Lu Xun · 1922-35; 1935 collection
10%
Manufacturing Consent (Mid-late (political work))
Noam Chomsky · 1988 (with Edward S. Herman)
5%
On the Origin of Species
Charles Darwin · 1859 (first edition); five subsequent revised editions in Darwin's lifetime
5%
Being and Nothingness
Jean-Paul Sartre · 1943 (Paris, under German occupation)
5%
The Order of Things
Michel Foucault · 1966
5%
The History of Sexuality (Late (his last major project))
Michel Foucault · 1976 (vol. 1); 1984 (vols. 2-3, shortly before Foucault's death); vol. 4 (Confessions of the Flesh) published posthumously 2018
5%
The Nature and Destiny of Man (Mid-late (Niebuhr's major systematic work))
Reinhold Niebuhr · 1941 (vol. I, Human Nature); 1943 (vol. II, Human Destiny) — based on the Gifford Lectures, Edinburgh, 1939
5%
The Social Contract (Late (after the two Discourses; the political conclusion of Rousseau's mature thought))
Jean-Jacques Rousseau · 1762
5%
A Black Theology of Liberation (Early (the systematic founding text of the field))
James Cone · 1970 (the second of Cone's books and the systematic statement of the position announced in Black Theology and Black Power, 1969)
5%
The Irony of American History (Late (Niebuhr's major Cold War political-theological book))
Reinhold Niebuhr · 1952
5%
Achieving Our Country (Late)
Richard Rorty · 1998
5%
Time and Narrative (Late)
Paul Ricoeur · 1983-85 (3 vols; English 1984-88)
5%
Memory, History, Forgetting (Late)
Paul Ricoeur · 2000 (French; English 2004)
5%
Gender Trouble (Early)
Judith Butler · 1990
5%
The Methodology of Scientific Research Programmes (Late)
Imre Lakatos · 1978 (posthumous; key essays from 1968-71)
5%
Against Method (Mid)
Paul Feyerabend · 1975 (1st edn); 1988 (2nd); 1993 (3rd)
5%
Muqaddimah (Late)
Ibn Khaldūn (ʿAbd al-Raḥmān) · 1377
5%
Frontiers of Justice (Late)
Martha C. Nussbaum · 2006
5%
De Rerum Natura (On the Nature of Things) (Mid)
Titus Lucretius Carus · c. 55 BCE
5%
New Science (Late)
Giambattista Vico · 1725 (1st edn); 1730 (2nd); 1744 (3rd, definitive)
5%
Homo Sacer: Sovereign Power and Bare Life (Late)
Giorgio Agamben · 1995
5%
The Long Loneliness (Late)
Dorothy Day · 1952
5%
Rerum Novarum (Late)
Pope Leo XIII · 1891 (15 May)
5%
The Voice of the Voiceless (Late)
Óscar Romero · 1977-80 (collected pastoral letters)
5%
One Hundred Years of Solitude (Cien años de soledad) (Mid)
Gabriel García Márquez · 1967
5%
The Magic Mountain (Der Zauberberg) (Late)
Thomas Mann · 1912-24 (composed); 1924 (published)
5%
1984 (Nineteen Eighty-Four) (Late)
George Orwell (Eric Arthur Blair) · 1949
5%
Long Walk to Freedom (Late)
Nelson Mandela · 1994
5%
The Autobiography of Malcolm X (Late)
Malcolm X with Alex Haley · 1965
5%
On the Principles of Political Economy and Taxation (Late)
David Ricardo · 1817
5%
The Golden Notebook (Mid)
Doris Lessing · 1957-62
5%
A Realist Theory of Science (Mid)
Roy Bhaskar · 1975 (1st ed.); 1978 (2nd ed.); 2008 (3rd ed.)
5%
God of the Oppressed (Mid)
James H. Cone · 1975
5%
On Job (Late)
Gustavo Gutiérrez · 1987 (Spanish Hablar de Dios desde el sufrimiento del inocente); 1987 (English)
5%
Jesus the Liberator (Late)
Jon Sobrino · 1991 (Spanish Jesucristo liberador); 1993 (English)
5%
Call to Arms (Nahan) (Mid)
Lu Xun · 1923
5%
Vigrahavyāvartanī (Early)
Nāgārjuna · c. 150-250 AD
5%
Śūnyatāsaptati (Mid)
Nāgārjuna · c. 150-250 AD
5%
Yuktiṣaṣṭikā (Mid)
Nāgārjuna · c. 150-250 AD

Personas with Dialectical Materialism as a declared influence

75%  Karl Marx 35%  Theodor Adorno 30%  Frantz Fanon 25%  Walter Benjamin 25%  Lu Xun 20%  Jürgen Habermas 15%  Simone Weil 15%  Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel 15%  Gustavo Gutiérrez 15%  James Cone 15%  Cornel West 15%  bell hooks 15%  Donna Haraway 15%  Dorothy Day 15%  Achille Mbembe 10%  Jean-Paul Sartre 10%  Simone de Beauvoir 10%  Audre Lorde 10%  Roy Bhaskar 10%  Alasdair MacIntyre 10%  Toni Morrison 10%  James Baldwin 5%  Nelson Rolihlahla Mandela -10%  Eleanor Roosevelt -20%  Nikolai Berdyaev

How Dialectical Materialism resolves each dilemma

57 resolved positions across 4 dimensions, including 11 distinctive where the majority of schools go the other way.

Each dimension is sorted so minority positions come first. Mainstream positions are folded into an expandable list.

Time · 9 dilemmas · 3 distinctive

Persistence, the future, and the direction of becoming.

Distinctive · only 10% of schools agree (20/208)
Do you really choose?
If the brain is a physical system and physical systems are governed by laws, then every choice is also a chain of causes — which raises the question of what was really left to choose.
Choice is real within a determined order — agency and determinism aren’t opposites.
On this view, the future is determined and you are genuinely choosing. Those aren't contradictory because the determination runs through you rather than around you: your reasoning, deliberation, and assent are the way the determined outcome gets settled. Choice is what it feels like from …
Roads not taken The future is open and you are a genuine origin of it. (69%) · Choice is structural illusion — every event is fixed by the prior state. (10%) · Even if the universe is undetermined, you are not the chooser. (6%)
Distinctive · only 10% of schools agree (20/208)
Are addicts responsible for their addiction?
Addiction looks from one angle like the textbook case of agency failing — a person doing what they don't, in any meaningful sense, want to do. From another angle it looks like agency at work in hard conditions. Which it is depends on what agency is.
The addict is genuinely responsible within a determined order.
On this view, the addict is acting within a determined order but is genuinely acting — making decisions, endorsing or resisting urges, seeking or refusing help. Responsibility attaches not because some uncaused choice happened, but because the addict is the kind of agent through which …
Roads not taken The addict could have chosen otherwise — that's why recovery is real. (69%) · The addict's behaviour is the outcome of causes; 'responsibility' is a useful fiction, not a metaphysical fact. (10%) · Even if the universe is undetermined, the addict isn't the chooser. (6%)
Distinctive · only 10% of schools agree (20/208)
Should we hold AI systems responsible for what they do?
When an autonomous AI takes an action that harms someone, the question of who or what is responsible — the developer, the operator, the model itself — turns on whether the model is the kind of thing that can be a responsible agent.
The AI can be a genuine agent within determined conditions — and therefore genuinely responsible.
On this view, what makes a being responsible is not indeterminism but the kind of process the being is. An AI that deliberates, considers consequences, can be given reasons, and modifies its behaviour on reflection is doing what responsible agency is, even if its underlying …
Roads not taken An AI without a free will is not the kind of thing that can be responsible. (69%) · An AI's behaviour is fully determined by training and input; 'responsibility' applies if at all to its makers. (10%) · Neither AIs nor anyone else are the locus of free agency; the question is the wrong one. (6%)
6 mainstream positions

Matter · 7 dilemmas · 4 distinctive

What stuff is — fundamental, relational, or appearance.

Distinctive · only 16% of schools agree (33/208)
What is money?
The question of what money is — a measured store of real value, an agreed-on practice, a relational ledger of debts, or just a name we apply to many different things — sits behind every argument about inflation, cryptocurrency, debt, and the state.
Money is a social practice — its content is what we make it.
On this view, money is exactly what societies do that performs the monetary functions. There is no fact about whether something is 'really' money beyond whether it is used as money. A community that decides shell beads or carbon credits or proof-of-work hashes count as …
Roads not taken Money is a real institution with intrinsic features. (55%) · Money is the ledger of obligations among real people. (14%) · “Money” names a family of practices — the definition question is nominal. (8%)
Distinctive · only 16% of schools agree (33/208)
What is a nation?
Whether a nation is a real moral community with intrinsic character, a constructed legal-political artifact, a web of kinship and shared history, an imagined community, or a conventional partition of a deeper unity — these are real ontological positions with sharply different political downstream.
A nation is a constructed polity — a project, not a discovery.
On this view, nations are made: by treaties, by wars, by deliberate institution-building, by the slow work of collective practice. There is nothing intrinsic about a national kind; what exists is the practice. What we owe the nation is what we owe any institution we …
Roads not taken A nation is a real moral community with intrinsic character. (55%) · A nation is the web of kinship, ancestry, and shared land that hosts a people. (14%) · “Nation” names a family of practices imaginatively held together. (8%)
Distinctive · only 16% of schools agree (33/208)
What makes someone male or female?
Whether sex is a real biological kind, a constructed social category, a relational identity, a label applied to varied phenomena, or a conventional distinction within a deeper unity is the ontological question the contemporary dispute about gender is mostly about.
Gender is constructed; what counts as male or female reflects practice.
On this view, while biological features exist, what they socially mean — what counts as a man or a woman, what roles attach, how the categories are policed and revised — is the work of social practice. The categories are real but constructed; revising them …
Roads not taken Sex is a real biological kind with given content. (55%) · Sex and gender are constituted by relations of recognition. (14%) · “Male” and “female” are family-resemblance terms — no single essence. (8%)
Distinctive · only 16% of schools agree (33/208)
Should we edit the human germline?
Whether human nature is a given biological kind, a constructed category, a relational achievement, a family-resemblance cluster, or a conventional distinction within deeper unity is the ontological question the policy debate over heritable gene editing is mostly about.
The categories we count as 'human' are emergent from practice; germline editing is a practice-revision like any other.
On this view, biological facts about the genome exist, but what we count as 'human nature' is downstream of practice. The germline is one more thing humans now have technical access to; the question is not whether the practice transgresses an essence but whether the …
Roads not taken Human nature is a real biological kind given by reproductive biology or by creation; editing the germline transgresses what is given. (55%) · Personhood is constituted by relations of descent and kinship; germline editing reshapes the relational fabric. (14%) · 'Human nature' is a cluster term without a single essence; the editing question is empirical, not metaphysical. (8%)
3 mainstream positions

Observer · 37 dilemmas · 4 distinctive

Mind, agency, and the knower's relation to the known.

Distinctive · only 5% of schools agree (10/208)
Who is the moral primary — the individual, the community, the cosmos, the class, or the species?
Different traditions take fundamentally different things to be the basic moral-political unit.
The class or historical movement is the moral primary.
Persons are constituted by their position in social-historical struggle.
Roads not taken The discrete person is the moral primary. (38%) · The community of persons is the moral primary. (28%) · The cosmic-religious order is the moral primary. (16%)
Distinctive · only 16% of schools agree (33/208)
When does a person begin?
The political question of abortion sits atop an older ontological one: at what point does there exist a someone — a being with moral standing — rather than merely the materials from which one will form?
A person comes into being gradually, as the capacities of a mind develop.
On this view, personhood is not a status conferred at a moment but a property of beings with certain capacities — to feel, to suffer, to prefer, eventually to reflect. A zygote has none of these; a late-term fetus has many; a newborn has most. …
Roads not taken A person exists from conception — when a new being comes into existence. (55%) · Personhood is conferred by being-in-relation. (14%) · The question presupposes a fact of the matter that isn’t there. (8%)
Distinctive · only 16% of schools agree (33/208)
What is marriage?
Behind every disagreement about how marriage should be defined is a prior disagreement about what kind of thing it is — a given order to be recognized, a practice to be negotiated, or a web of relations to be woven.
Marriage is a practice we shape — its content is what we make it.
On this view, marriage is a human institution shaped by law, custom, and the agreements of those who enter it. There is no fixed essence to discover, only practices to negotiate. As societies change — granting women legal personhood, recognizing no-fault divorce, extending the institution …
Roads not taken Marriage has a given form — it’s a kind of thing we recognize, not make. (55%) · Marriage is constituted by the web of relations it creates. (14%) · “Marriage” names a family of practices — the definition question is nominal. (8%)
Distinctive · only 23% of schools agree (47/208)
Does history have a direction or meaning?
Is history the unfolding of progress, the recovery of lost truth, a cyclical recurrence, the approach of consummation — or none of these?
History is the gradual unfolding of improvement or liberation.
Time bends, slowly, toward greater understanding, freedom, or fuller realization.
Roads not taken History is not where the deepest truth lives. (36%) · History is oriented toward a decisive consummation. (19%) · History recurs in cosmic cycles. (17%)
33 mainstream positions
Could causation work backwards? Causation runs one way — the arrow of time is real and structural. 68% Is the asymmetry between memory and anticipation a real feature of time, or just of us? The asymmetry is real because time itself has a real direction. 68% Is the arrow of time a real feature of the cosmos, or only of how we describe it? The arrow is real and structural; the asymmetry isn't an artifact of description. 68% Is environmental damage ever truly permanent? Damage is real and permanent on the relevant timescales. There is no recovery; there is only limitation. 66% Can a civilization recover from collapse? Civilizational complexity is hard to build and easy to lose; recovery is at best partial. 66% Does the second law of thermodynamics mean something morally? Entropy is what time is. The moral weight, if any, is the weight of working against the current. 66% Is truth universal, tradition-bound, situated, or constructed? Truth is mind-independent, universal, accessible in principle to all. 66% What is our place in nature? Active in a real nature — we cultivate, steward, transform. 50% Should we colonize space? Cultivating worlds beyond Earth is the next form of stewardship. 50% Is genetic engineering of food stewardship or domination? Genetic modification is cultivation by other means. 50% Does environmental harm in another country bind me morally? Moral obligation tracks the relations one is in; distance does matter, structurally. 50% Can prayer for someone far away affect them? Prayer changes the pray-er, not the prayed-for. 47% Are coincidences ever more than coincidence? Coincidence is exactly what the math says it is. The pattern is in the noticer. 47% Is divine omniscience compatible with human freedom? The observer is in time; foreknowledge across times raises real freedom problems. 46% Does meditation reveal something genuinely timeless? Meditators are bounded observers reporting unusual brain states; the 'timeless' is metaphorical. 46% Does prayer change God's mind? If there is an addressee at all, it is in time; prayer is communication, and may genuinely change what comes next. 46% Are the dead morally present to the living? Observers are bounded by their own moment, and no further agency makes the dead present. 43% What kind of religious-theological authority does the tradition recognize? The category does not apply — the school is non-religious. 42% What makes someone the same person over time? You are your body — continuity is bodily continuity. 36% Is the late-stage dementia patient still the person their spouse married? Same body, same person — even when the cognitive pattern has changed. 36% If a teleporter copied and destroyed you, would you have survived? Different body, different person — you died in the scanner. 36% Is reality fundamentally digital? No — continuous fields, classical limits, analog deep structure. 36% Are there indivisible units of experience? No — continuous Jamesian stream, phenomenological lived time. 36% Is memory stored or reconstructed? Reconstructed — continuous re-narrating, no fixed engrams. 36% Do animals have moral standing comparable to humans? Animal minds are real because biology is the substrate of mind. 31% Could a fetal brain organoid in a petri dish be conscious? Brain tissue can in principle do what brains do; the question is integration. 31% What happens to "you" when you die? Death is genuinely the end. 29% Could an AI have a mind that matters? No — mind is what a biological brain does, and an LLM has no brain. 29% Should we trust expert testimony when we can't verify it? Trust the practice, not the practitioner. 13% Is religious revelation a real source of knowledge? 'Revelation' is a category communities construct for what counts as authoritative. 13% Does an LLM 'know' the things it correctly produces? Whether an LLM 'knows' is the constructive question the practice has to answer. 13% How is knowledge of reality produced? Through historical-critical engagement and the working-out of contradictions. 12% Is salvation, liberation, or fulfillment individual or communal? Liberation is the collective historical work of the oppressed. 4%
Information · 4 dilemmas, all mainstream
Jump to school (208)
#1 #2 #3 #4 #5 #6 #7 #8 #9 #10 #11 #12 #13 #14 #15 #16 #17 #18 #19 #20 #21 #22 #23 #24 #25 #26 #27 #28 #29 #30 #31 #32 #33 #34 #35 #36 #37 #38 #39 #40 #41 #42 #43 #44 #45 #46 #47 #48 #49 #50 #51 #52 #53 #54 #55 #56 #57 #58 #59 #60 #61 #62 #63 #64 #65 #66 #67 #68 #69 #70 #71 #72 #73 #74 #75 #76 #77 #78 #79 #80 #81 #82 #83 #84 #85 #86 #87 #88 #89 #90 #91 #92 #93 #94 #95 #96 #97 #98 #99 #100 #101 #102 #103 #104 #105 #106 #107 #108 #109 #110 #111 #112 #113 #114 #115 #116 #117 #118 #119 #120 #121 #122 #123 #124 #125 #126 #127 #128 #129 #130 #131 #132 #133 #134 #135 #136 #137 #138 #139 #140 #141 #142 #143 #144 #145 #146 #147 #148 #149 #150 #151 #152 #153 #154 #155 #156 #157 #158 #159 #160 #161 #162 #163 #164 #165 #166 #167 #168 #169 #170 #171 #172 #173 #174 #175 #176 #177 #178 #179 #180 #181 #182 #183 #184 #185 #186 #187 #188 #189 #190 #191 #192 #193 #194 #195 #196 #197 #198 #199 #200 #201 #202 #203 #204 #205 #206 #207 #208