A Treatise Concerning Religious Affections
Edwards's 1746 analysis of true and false religious experience — the major theological response to the First Great Awakening
Tradition: American Reformed-Calvinist evangelical theology
True religion consists chiefly in holy affections — Edwards's twelve signs distinguishing genuine spiritual experience from its counterfeits
A Treatise Concerning Religious Affections is the most important American work of evangelical theology in the eighteenth century and the major theological response to the First Great Awakening (c. 1734-43). Edwards, who had been a central figure in the Awakening, writes to address the question: how does one distinguish genuine religious experience — experience that bears the marks of true conversion — from its many emotional, social, and pathological counterfeits? The treatise has three parts. Part 1 argues that "true religion, in great part, consists in holy affections" — religious experience is irreducibly affective, not merely intellectual. Part 2 lists twelve signs that are not certain marks of true grace (intensity of experience, ability to speak fluently of religious things, etc.). Part 3 lists twelve signs that are reliable marks (a transformed conception of God's glory, persevering practice, etc.). The book founded American evangelical reflection on conversion and Christian experience and has been continuously influential in evangelical theology — particularly through Mark Noll, John Piper, and the recent Edwards revival.
Author
Editions cited
- Religious Affections (Yale Works of Jonathan Edwards, vol. 2, John E. Smith ed., 1959)
- A Treatise Concerning Religious Affections (Banner of Truth Trust)
- Selected from the Works of Jonathan Edwards (multiple selections include the Affections in part)
School Embodiments
Religious Affections is the most important American Reformed-Calvinist treatment of religious experience. The doctrine of effectual calling and the regenerate transformation of the affections is pure Reformed theology.
"True religion, in great part, consists in holy affections." (Religious Affections, Part I, the central thesis)
Edwards is the canonical American evangelical theologian and Religious Affections is the foundational evangelical analysis of conversion experience. Twentieth-century evangelical thought (Noll, Piper, the Banner of Truth movement) traces directly to this work.
"The first sign that affections are gracious is that they arise from the influence of the Spirit of God on the heart." (Religious Affections, Part III)
A complicated relation: Edwards's analysis of religious experience anticipates and shapes (negatively as well as positively) subsequent liberal-theological treatments of religious experience — Schleiermacher reads similar categories differently, William James cites Edwards in Varieties.
"There is a kind of sense or taste of the divine excellence." (Religious Affections, Part III; cited in James's Varieties as a classic statement)
Edwards engages Locke's empiricism extensively. The "new spiritual sense" doctrine is modelled on Lockean sensory ideas — a new spiritual perception bestowed by grace.
"A spiritual perception, an inward divine sense of things." (Religious Affections, the Lockean spiritual-sense doctrine)
A retrospective affinity: Edwards's emphasis on the existential-personal appropriation of religious truth, on the difference between notional and experimental knowledge, has proto-existentialist structure.
"There is a difference between having a rational judgment that honey is sweet, and having a sense of its sweetness." (Religious Affections, the famous distinction)
A retrospective affinity: Religious Affections is a sustained descriptive-phenomenological analysis of religious experience in its various modes — affective, cognitive, volitional, behavioural.
"The understanding and the will are both engaged in true affection." (Religious Affections, Part I)
Edwards is a robust theological realist: God really exists, grace really transforms, religious affections really track theological realities or their counterfeits.
"The objective ground of holy affections is the divine excellence itself." (Religious Affections, Part III)
Edwards's metaphysics has Neoplatonic elements — the divine beauty as the objective ground of religious affection, the soul's ascent through love to participation in God.
"The beauty and excellency of God." (Religious Affections, the Neoplatonic objective ground)
A complicated relation: Edwards critiques Stoic apatheia (religious experience must be affective, not merely rational) but his analysis of governed affections has Stoic structure.
"True religion is no mere apathy." (Religious Affections, paraphrasing Part I)
Internal Tensions
Religious Affections has been criticised both by less-evangelical Protestants (for too sharply distinguishing the regenerate from the unregenerate) and by stricter Reformed theologians (for too much emphasis on experience as the test of regeneration). Edwards's relation to the broader Awakening movement and to its excesses (which he himself helped catalyse in 1734-35 Northampton) is a continuing question. The work's status as both a defence of the Awakening and a criticism of its excesses gives it a dialectical structure that has been a continuing point of debate in Edwards scholarship (Goen, Marsden, Murray, Smith).
I. Time
Newtonian-substantival time as the background; God's eternal decree determines the temporal unfolding of grace in the elect.
Attributes
II. Space
Newtonian background space; the inward space of the soul as the relevant theological subject.
Attributes
III. Matter
Embodied human life; the body as the medium of the soul's affections and behaviours.
Attributes
IV. Observer
The regenerate believer, embodied, with the new spiritual sense bestowed by grace. Plural, both active in moral life and passive in receiving grace. Personal-providential God as ultimate.
Attributes
V. Energy
The affections themselves — the dynamic energetic structure of human responsiveness to divine reality.
Attributes
VI. Information
The transformed self-knowledge of the regenerate, with its characteristic structure of affections, preserved through perseverance.
Attributes
Personas that cite this work
Personas with the nearest attribute fingerprint
Historical figures whose own classification on the same six-dimensional grid lands closest to this work's. Computed by attribute-agreement on coordinates both address.
Computed school proximity
The work's attribute fingerprint scored against all schools using the same quiz scorer. Useful as a sanity check on the hand-curated embodiments above.
How A Treatise Concerning Religious Affections resolves each dilemma
51 resolved positions across 4 dimensions, including 6 distinctive where the majority of schools go the other way · 6 unaligned.
Each dimension is sorted so minority positions come first. Mainstream positions are folded into an expandable list.
Time · 9 dilemmas · 5 distinctive
Persistence, the future, and the direction of becoming.