School #44

Occasionalism

Al-Ghazali, Malebranche, Geulincx

Occasionalism holds that no created substance possesses genuine causal power. God alone is the true cause of every event at every instant; what we perceive as natural causation is merely the regularity of God's habitual willing. Creatures provide the "occasion" for God's action but never the cause.

I. Time

Extent Finite
Ontological Status Emergent
Grain Discrete
Freedom Deterministic
Traversability Linear
Dimensionality One
Direction Uni-directional

Time is emergent and finite — it is not an independently existing container but the sequence of divinely willed instants. God recreates the entire universe at each moment; temporal continuity is God's habit, not a natural necessity. Time is discrete (each instant is a fresh divine act), linear, deterministic (all events follow God's will), and uni-directional because God has chosen to order instants in this way.

II. Space

Extent Finite
Ontological Status Emergent
Curvature Flat
Dimensionality Three
Locality Local

Space is emergent, finite, flat, and local — it is the spatial arrangement God wills at each instant, not an independently existing medium. Space is three-dimensional as God has chosen to create it. There is no natural spatial causation between objects; any appearance of spatial interaction is God acting on the occasion of one object's proximity to another.

III. Matter

Extent Finite
Ontological Status Emergent
Conservation Non-conserved
Dimensionality Three
Locality Local

Matter is emergent and finite — it has no intrinsic causal power and is entirely dependent on God's continuous creative sustenance. Conservation is non-conserved: God could annihilate or create matter at will; the apparent stability of the material world reflects only the regularity of God's habitual willing. Matter is local: objects occupy determinate positions by divine arrangement.

IV. Observer

Time Instance Single
Space Instance Single
Extent of Knowledge Immediate
Retainment of Knowledge Total
Physicality Both
Agency Passive
Number Plural
Time Instance: Single — the observer exists only in the present instant, which God recreates moment by moment; there is no creaturely persistence across time without God's continuous re-willing
Space Instance: Single — the observer occupies a single spatial location at each divinely sustained instant
Extent of Knowledge: Immediate — the creature has no independent epistemic power; all knowledge is what God grants in the present moment through occasioning perceptions in the mind
Retainment of Knowledge: Total — God sustains the continuity of memory across instants as part of his habitual ordering; what is known is retained by divine sustenance
Physicality: Both — Malebranche maintains the reality of both mind and body, but neither has causal power; the soul is embodied yet its union with the body is sustained entirely by God
Agency: Passive — the creature has no genuine causal agency; all apparent actions are God's doing; the human will provides only the occasion, never the efficient cause
Consciousness: Present — consciousness exists as a genuine feature of the created mind, though it produces nothing by its own power
Number: Plural — multiple observers exist as distinct created minds, each sustained and coordinated by God's continuous action

V. Energy

Extent Finite
Ontological Status Emergent
Conservation Non-conserved
Dispersibility Irreversible

Finite and emergent — energy has no independent existence; it is recreated at each instant by God's direct action. Conservation: Non-conserved — since God is the sole cause, he is free to create or annihilate energy at will; conservation is merely his customary habit, not a necessary law. Dispersibility: Irreversible — the directionality of physical processes reflects God's chosen ordering of instants, not any intrinsic property of energy itself.

VI. Information

Ontological Status Emergent
Conservation Non-conserved
Granularity Continuous

Information transfer between events requires divine intervention — there is no natural informational causation between created things. God is the sole conduit of information. Information is emergent because it arises only through God's momentary creative acts. It is non-conserved because without God's continuous intervention, no information would persist from one moment to the next. It is continuous because God's creative acts are not quantized.

← #43 Samkhya All Schools #45 Object-Oriented Ontology (OOO) →

Jump to school

#1 #2 #3 #4 #5 #6 #7 #8 #9 #10 #11 #12 #13 #14 #15 #16 #17 #18 #19 #20 #21 #22 #23 #24 #25 #26 #27 #28 #29 #30 #31 #32 #33 #34 #35 #36 #37 #38 #39 #40 #41 #42 #43 #44 #45 #46 #47 #48 #49 #50 #51 #52 #53 #54 #55 #56 #57 #58 #59 #60 #61