Time, Matter, Observer, Energy & Information
The cognitive biography without location
Missing dimension: Space
Overview
This quintuplet removes space and asks what remains: a material, energetic, informational observer existing through time but without spatial extension or location. It is the domain of pure biography — the temporal arc of a knowing being who metabolizes energy, processes information, and exists in matter, but is abstracted from the spatial world. Could a mind exist in time without occupying space? Could consciousness be a temporal-material-energetic-informational process without spatial extension?
Central Tension
The tension is between the apparent inseparability of matter and space (every material thing occupies space) and the conceptual possibility of a non-spatial mind. If consciousness is fundamentally a temporal-informational process running on material-energetic hardware, perhaps space is not essential — perhaps a point-like or dimensionless observer could exist in time, processing information, consuming energy, made of matter, but occupying no spatial extension. This is a limit-case that tests our intuitions about the relationship between mind and space.
Key Philosophical Questions
- Can a material observer exist in time without spatial extension, or does matter necessarily occupy space?
- Is consciousness a spatial phenomenon (distributed across brain regions) or a temporal one (a process unfolding in time)?
- Could a non-spatial observer process information — and what would "processing" mean without spatial channels for information flow?
- Does the absence of space collapse the observer into a dimensionless point of temporal-material-energetic-informational existence?
Schools of Thought
Matter cannot exist without space; this quintuplet is physically impossible, since every material-energetic observer must occupy spatial extension.
Reality is temporal process; space may be derivative of temporal-informational relations. A non-spatial but temporal observer is conceivable as pure process.
The observer is a stream of momentary material-energetic-informational events over time; spatial extension is a convention, not an essential feature of the mind-stream.
The observer is a temporal information-processing pattern; if the pattern can be instantiated in matter-energy over time without spatial extension, consciousness may be spatial-independent.
Human observers are always spatially embodied, but the soul may be conceived as a non-spatial reality existing in time, sustained by God's power, and bearing God's informational image.
Synthesis
Without space, this quintuplet describes the mind as pure temporal process: a material-energetic-informational observer existing through time but nowhere in particular. It is a philosophical thought experiment that tests the necessity of spatial extension for consciousness, embodiment, and informational processing.
Related Dimension Quadruplets