Clear all
Persona #255

Patanjali

c. 2nd century BCE
Compiler of the Yoga Sutras, systematiser of raja yoga

Yoga is the cessation of the fluctuations of the mind — still the waves, and the seer rests in its own nature

Attribute Fingerprint

Rows where personas disagree are highlighted in gold. The full ontology grid (32 attributes) is shown.

Attribute Patanjali
Time · Extent Infinite
Time · Ontological Status Substantival
Time · Grain Continuous
Time · Freedom Both
Time · Traversability Cyclical
Time · Dimensionality One
Time · Direction Uni-directional
Space · Extent Infinite
Space · Ontological Status Substantival
Space · Curvature not engaged
Space · Dimensionality Three
Space · Locality not engaged
Matter · Extent Infinite
Matter · Ontological Status Substantival
Matter · Conservation Conserved
Matter · Dimensionality Three
Matter · Locality Local
Observer · Time Instance Single
Observer · Space Instance Single
Observer · Knowledge Extent Total
Observer · Knowledge Retainment Total
Observer · Physicality Both
Observer · Agency Active
Observer · Number Plural
Observer · Metaphysical Agency Personal
Observer · Moral Authority Tradition
Observer · Theological Method Mystical
Energy · Extent Infinite
Energy · Ontological Status Substantival
Energy · Conservation Conserved
Energy · Dispersibility Reversible
Information · Ontological Status Substantival
Information · Cosmic Conservation Conserved
Information · Personal Conservation Conserved
Information · Granularity Continuous

Dimension-by-Dimension Evidence

What each persona's writings reveal about their stance on each of the six dimensions.

Time

Patanjali

Time in the Yoga Sutras follows the Indian cosmological framework: infinite, cyclical (kalpas, yugas), with the three gunas in perpetual transformation. Purusha, however, is beyond time entirely. "Krama-anyatvam parinamah-anyatve hetuh — The succession of changes is the cause of the difference in transformations." (Yoga Sutra III.15; IV.33) Time freedom is "Both": prakriti unfolds deterministically according to the gunas, but purusha is free, and the yogin achieves kaivalya by exercising that freedom.

Space

Patanjali

Space is the arena of prakriti's transformations — substantival, infinite (there are innumerable worlds in Indian cosmology), three-dimensional in the ordinary sense. Purusha is non-spatial. "By performing samyama on the relation between body and space … the yogin achieves lightness." (Yoga Sutra III.42, paraphrase)

Matter

Patanjali

Prakriti is the eternal, uncreated material principle composed of the three gunas (sattva, rajas, tamas). It is conserved — matter-energy is never created or destroyed, only transformed. "Prakriti is the eternal material cause … its transformations produce the entire manifest world." (Samkhya Karika 9, which Patanjali presupposes)

Observer

Patanjali

The observer is purusha — pure witnessing consciousness. In the unenlightened state, purusha misidentifies with chitta (mind-matter), producing suffering. Through the eight limbs of yoga, the observer disentangles itself and realises its true nature as free, omniscient, and beyond prakriti. Active agency in practice; passive witness-consciousness at the metaphysical level. Ishvara — a special, personal purusha — offers grace. "Drashtuh svarupe avasthanam — Then the seer abides in its own nature." (Yoga Sutra I.3)

Energy

Patanjali

Prana (vital energy) is a manifestation of prakriti — substantival, conserved, and reversible (through pranayama and tapas the yogin can redirect energy upward). "Pranayama is regulation of the movement of inhalation and exhalation." (Yoga Sutra II.49) The cosmic energy of the gunas is conserved across the cycles of creation and dissolution.

Information

Patanjali

The samskaras (latent impressions) and vasanas (habitual tendencies) stored in chitta constitute personal information — and they are conserved across lifetimes until burned up by yoga. Cosmic information is conserved in the eternal purusha-prakriti structure. "Samskaras are the accumulated impressions of past actions … they determine future births." (Yoga Sutra II.12–13, paraphrase) Liberation (kaivalya) is the exhaustion of personal karmic information, not its destruction but its resolution.

Internal Tensions

Where each persona's working synthesis strains against itself.

Patanjali

The central tension in Patanjali is between the radical dualism inherited from Samkhya — purusha and prakriti are utterly distinct — and the practical yoga that requires them to interact. If purusha is pure, passive consciousness, how does it "get entangled" with prakriti in the first place? The doctrine of avidya (ignorance) does not fully resolve this, because ignorance is itself a modification of prakriti, not of purusha. A second tension: Ishvara (God) is introduced as a "special purusha" but plays no cosmogonic role — a theistic gesture within an essentially atheistic metaphysics.